• Full FrameEducation Week's Photo Blog

    Observing an Uncertain Future for School Districts in North Carolina

    by Charles Borst posted June 17, 2015

    On assignment for Education Week, photographer Justin Cook reflects on his return to his familial roots as he documented two North Carolina school districts that benefited from the Obama administration’s education improvement agenda, and now face dwindling federal funds.

    A giant dresser on Hamilton Street stands in homage on to the furniture industry in downtown High Point, N.C. According to American Community Survey 2013 5-year estimates, 21 percent of High Point's 102,924 population lives in poverty, and 32 percent of children under 18 live in poverty. (Justin Cook)

    A giant dresser on Hamilton Street stands in homage to the furniture industry in downtown High Point, N.C. –Justin Cook for Education Week

    I knew High Point, North Carolina, because my dad was born there, and my grandmother told me lots of stories about growing up on Montlieu Avenue. I worked in a camera store on Main Street one summer in college. I went to high school down the road in Greensboro, so an assignment in Guilford county schools was like going home. But photographing at Parkview Expressive Arts Magnet School was like working at the center of my being: I’m a product of an arts magnet elementary in Montgomery, Ala. Without that experience, who knows where I would be today. I doubt I’d be shooting photos for Education Week.

    The mood I set out to capture was “uncertainty.” What will happen to all the progress when some of the federal funds, specifically from President Obama’s Race to the Top initiative, dry up? Especially in North Carolina’s Title I schools, with the highest percentages of students from low-income families? Especially in a state where teachers have some of the lowest pay in the nation?

    A summer storm lingers over Parkview Expressive Arts Magnet School in High Point, N.C. on Sunday, May 31, 2015. Parkview stands to lose several federal Race-to-the-Top grants and other funding that has helped improve the school once President Obama leaves office. (Justin Cook)

    A summer storm lingers over Parkview Expressive Arts Magnet School in High Point, N.C. Parkview stands to lose several federal Race to the Top grants and other funding, which have spurred academic improvements at the school. –Justin Cook for Education Week

    I arrived in High Point on a Sunday afternoon, checked into my hotel, and immediately drove to the school. I wanted to walk the neighborhood and make some landscape images. It was about 6:45 p.m. and the sky was dark with thunderclouds to the west. The sun sets after 8:30 p.m. this time of year, and the light was only getting better. There, in the school parking lot, was the vista I sought: A thunderhead towered in a white plume beyond the school, its base churning black ready to burst. I made some frames, then hurried down the street to the park that overlooked the school for a better view. A family with two little kids passed me on the sidewalk. “Mister, you better get inside, it’s about to rain,” a little boy hollered. A cold wind rushed over the hill. The cloud broke in the distance before it could reach us.

    I returned to my car and drove downtown in the drizzle to capture more landscapes. High Point’s center is lined with quaint shops, restaurants, a theater, and posh furniture-showcase buildings. Economic diversification has helped High Point survive the outsourcing of the furniture industry that is still central to its economy. But if you drive less than a mile from downtown, it’s clear the investment hasn’t reached everyone. Five-year estimates from the American Community Survey 2013 show that 21 percent of High Point’s 103,000 people live in poverty, and 32 percent of children under 18 live in poverty.

    Ginny Stanfield (Virginia Elliot) shares End of Grade scores with Ishlah Fate (CQ), 10, in her fifth grade math class at Parkview Expressive Arts Magnet School in High Point, N.C. on Monday, June 1, 2015. Fate was elated after scoring significantly higher on her EOG under Stansfield's instruction. After raising her student's test scores faster and higher than other teachers, Standfield won a $20,000 bonus from the Teacher Incentive Fund. She has reinvested most of that money into the classroom by spending it on supplies, prizes, food and even clothes for students. She says that smaller, personalized classes as a result of federal grants are integral to her students' success. (Justin Cook)

    Teacher Virginia Stanfield shares end-of-grade scores with Ishlah Fate in her 5th grade math class at Parkview. Ishlah was elated after scoring significantly higher on the test under Ms. Stansfield’s instruction. –Justin Cook for Education Week

    On Monday, I found that 5th grade math teacher Virginia Stanfield and her colleagues at Parkview seemed undeterred, and even driven by these circumstances. She’s raised her students’ test scores faster and higher than other teachers, and won a $20,000 bonus from the Teacher Incentive Fund. She has reinvested most of that money into the classroom, buying supplies, prizes, food, and even clothes for students.

    Ginny Stanfield (Virginia Elliot) and her prize closet in her fifth grade math class at Parkview Expressive Arts Magnet School in High Point, N.C. on Monday, June 1, 2015. After raising her student's test scores faster and higher than other teachers, Standfield won a $20,000 bonus from the Teacher Incentive Fund. She has reinvested most of that money into the classroom by spending it on supplies, prizes, food and even clothes for students. She says that smaller, personalized classes as a result of federal grants are integral to her students' success. (Justin Cook)

    Virginia Stanfield, a 5th grade math teacher at Parkview., used part of a $20,000 bonus to stock a closet with supplies and prizes for students. –Justin Cook for Education Week

    Federal grants have also equipped each of her 5th graders with tablets, which they use with many lessons. Stanfield says the arts programs offer her students new experiences and build confidence, and the real secrets to their success are the smaller class sizes (15 students), after-school tutoring, and personalized instruction afforded by the grants. Stanfield also reaches beyond the school walls and develops relationships with parents. Her students were focused, polite, and funny as she taught them how to develop a business plan to sell lemonade: Math through entrepreneurship.

    Donjana Wilson (CQ), 11, uses an iPad in Virginia Elliot's class math class (she goes by Ginni Stanfield). Thanks for federal grants, each fifth grader has access to an iPad at Parkview Expressive Arts Magnet School in High Point, N.C.  (Justin Cook)

    Donjana Wilson, 11, uses a tablet in Virginia Stanfield’s 5th-grade math class. Federal grants have enabled each student to have access to tablets at the Parkview. –Justin Cook for Education Week

    The next day, I drove about an hour from High Point and found that teachers at East Iredell Elementary in Statesville have become students themselves, of data. Three times a year, they collect academic performance data, and fill yellow folders with personalized instruction plans for each student. They hone in on where students perform below grade level, and adjust their curriculum accordingly. Intervention specialist Vikki Stevens and instructional facilitator Janna Sells help lead the charge with a battlefield sense of purpose. Their conference room looks more like a war room: the walls are plastered with giant sheets of paper, marker-scribbled with year-by-year data analysis, color-coded progress charts, and intervention strategies – their plans in a long slog to “save students.”

    (FAR LEFT) Janna Sells, instructional facilitator, at East Iredell Elementary School Statesville, N.C. celebrates with second grade teachers after discussing data that shows that most of second grade students are performing at or above their grade level during a Professional Learning Community meeting on Tuesday, June 2, 2015. (Justin Cook)

    Janna Sells, left, an instructional facilitator at East Iredell Elementary School in Statesville, N.C., celebrates with 2nd grade teachers after discussing data that show that most of 2nd grade students are performing at or above their grade level during a professional learning community meeting at the school. –Justin Cook for Education Week

    I photographed them as they met with teachers from several grade levels, and celebrated a successful school year. According to their numbers, 458 students at East Iredell performed below grade level at the beginning of the 2013-2014 school year, but by the end of the 2014-2015 school year that number dropped to 168. The staff seemed at once exhilarated and exhausted by their efforts.

    Student progress charts at East Iredell Elementary School Statesville, N.C. on Tuesday, June 2, 2015. Data is analyzed thrice yearly at the beginning, middle and end of the year. Red indicates percentages of students performing well below the grade level, yellow just below grade level, and green indicates at or above grade level. At the beginning of the 2013-2014 school year, 458 students were performing below grade level at East Iredell Elementary, and by the end of the 2014-2015 school year, only 168 were. (Justin Cook)

    A detail of charts that graph student progress at East Iredell. Data are analyzed thrice yearly at the beginning, middle, and end of the year. Red indicates percentages of students performing well below the grade level, yellow just below grade level, and green at or above grade level. –Justin Cook for Education Week

    Folders full of data and personalized intervention plans for every student stacked at East Iredell Elementary School in Statesville, N.C. on Tuesday, June 2, 2015. (Justin Cook)

    Folders full of data and personalized intervention plans for every student are stacked at East Iredell. –Justin Cook for Education Week

    Intervention Specialist Vikki Stevens at East Iredell Elementary School in Statesville, N.C. on Tuesday, June 2, 2015. Stevens analyzes data with Instructional Facilitator Janna Sells to find and execute ways to boost academic performance, but Stevens' position is funded by federal grant money and her position ends at the end of June 2015 when the grant expires. (Justin Cook)

    An intervention specialist at East Iredell, Vikki Stevens, faces an uncertain future herself, as federal monies that fund her position end in June. –Justin Cook for Education Week

    But the federal i3 grant that funds Stevens’ role at the school ends June 30th, and so does her job. She’s currently looking to see if she can stay at the school in another role, or move to another district that employs intervention specialists. In Statesville and High Point it was clear that while computing devices and technology may equip our kids for the times, old-fashioned relationships and intervention win their future.

    FROM LEFT: Serenity Estrada, 8, and Brianna Rodriguez, 8, (BOTH CQ) work on problems with Instructional Facilitator Janna Sells during a third grade math intervention session at East Iredell Elementary School in Statesville, N.C. on Tuesday, June 2, 2015. (Justin Cook)

    Serenity Estrada, 8, and Brianna Rodriguez, 8, work on problems with instructional facilitator Janna Sells during a 3rd grade math intervention session at East Iredell. –Justin Cook for Education Week

    Janna Sells, instructional facilitator, hugs third-grader Shamonica Branch (CQ), 8, at the end of the school day at East Iredell Elementary School in Statesville, N.C. on Tuesday, June 2, 2015. (Justin Cook)

    Janna Sells hugs 3rd grade student Shamonica Branch at the end of the school day at East Iredell. –Justin Cook for Education Week

     

    Photos and text by Justin Cook